Two pale butterflies gather nectar from yellow flowers

Which Came First, the Butterfly or the Flower? The Answer: Both!

A bee sips nectar from a bright yellow flower
The relatively flat surface of this flower makes it easy for the bee to rest upon it while gathering nectar and picking up pollen.

If you’ve ever taken a high school biology course, you may have learned that pollinators such as butterflies and bees evolved alongside flowers for their mutual benefit. The result of generations upon generations of plants and pollinators evolving side by side are what botanists have called “pollination syndromes.” These are fascinating systems that have much to teach us about the natural world—but recent research reveals they may not be as simple as botanists once thought.

This term “pollination syndromes” was coined when botanists in the 19th century noticed that flowers shaped like long tubes (like honeysuckles) are often pollinated by animals with long tongues or beaks. Relatively flat, bowl-shaped flowers (like daisies or sunflowers) tend to attract bees and butterflies with their less-than-streamlined bodies.

Meanwhile, some flowers produce foul odors that attract flies and carrion beetles, who are drawn by the scent. Other plants sport brilliant red flowers, and it’s no coincidence that they are pollinated by birds; the eyesight of birds allows them to see the color red particularly well.

It’s important to realize that the plants and their pollinators evolved together and shaped one another. Did coral honeysuckle evolve long tubular flowers to attract hummingbirds with long beaks, or did hummingbirds evolve long beaks to feed from coral honeysuckle? The answer is: both, at the same time. Changes in plants can influence changes in insects and animals, and vice versa.

Pollination syndromes are fun to study and to teach. For decades, teachers have presented students with the blooming patterns of plants and asked them to deduce how they are pollinated. For example, take a cactus with white flowers that only open at night. It doesn’t take Sherlock Holmes to reason that it must be pollinated at night by a nocturnal creature drawn to the light color of the flower. (Charles Darwin famously made a prediction that a particular orchid had to be pollinated by a never-before-seen moth, because of the shape of the flower. His prediction wasn’t confirmed until 21 years after his death.)

As botanists studied this phenomenon, they developed wonderful names for different types of pollination syndromes—jot these down for your next game of Scrabble. “Zoophily” is the general term for pollination by animals including insects, birds and bats. That suffix, “phily,” is from the Greek “phile,” and means “love;” “zoophily” means something like “animal love,” because these are plants that animals love. This is only the start. “Melittophily” is bee pollination, “phalaenophily” is moth pollination, and “psychophily” is butterfly pollination. Pollination by wind is the lyrical-sounding “anemophily.”

A brown hummingbird sits on a branch of plant with bright red flowers.
At the same time hummingbirds were evolving long beaks to suck nectar from tube-like flowers, plants were evolving tube-like flowers to attract hummingbirds.

Pollination syndromes are fun and fascinating—but, like so much in science, the best explanations are often oversimplifications.

A 2009 study found that maybe only one-third of flowering plants are pollinated by vectors accurately predicted based on the plant’s floral traits.*

That is, two-thirds of flowering plants are not as choosey as we expect them to be based on their looks. Many flowering plants are pollinated by a variety of different types of pollinators. A long-tubed flower might attract birds with long beaks, but it is often pollinated by a wide variety of creatures.

This doesn’t mean pollination syndromes aren’t useful. They provide context to talk about the ways in which species evolve, not in a vacuum but rather together, as a system that exerts pressure on its components in tandem. This process of tandem, related, interconnected change over time is called co-evolution.

Pollination syndromes may not be the universal truisms that botanists once believed, but they are still great examples of how the living world operates as an interconnected whole.

* Ollerton J.; Alarcón R.; Waser N.M.; Price M.V.; Watts S.; Cranmer L.; Hingston A. Peter; Rotenberry J. (2009). “A global test of the pollination syndrome hypothesis”. Annals of Botany. 103 (9): 1471–1480. doi:10.1093/aob/mcp031.

Related Articles

Goache painting of a Lemon by Olivia Garcia-Hassell
Learn

Explore Gouache for a More Creative New Year

Artistic creation can lighten your spirit and restore your soul. It’s easy to forget this truth in the hustle and bustle of every day life, but it’s worth remembering and exploring. If you’re looking to be a more centered, whole and creative person in 2023, consider trying Creative Art with Olivia.

Read More »
Orange blooms on a begonia against dark green leaves
Garden

Begonias Brighten January Days with Winter Blooms and Amazing Variety

Midwinter is a quiet time outside in the Garden, with most plants dormant until the days grow longer. But in the greenhouses devoted to the Garden’s Begonia Collection, excitement is growing as these remarkable plants get ready to bloom. Learn more about the incredible variety of begonias and get started growing your own.

Read More »
Dog Days
Engage

Dog Days Returns in 2023 for More Tail Wags and Nose Boops

Dog Days was introduced in 2022 and has been a howling success for canine fur babies and their human companions. This year, the Garden is expanding the program to one weekend a month, allowing pooches and their favorite people more opportunities to frolic on the grounds.

Read More »
Newsletter

Herbarium Reaches Transcription Milestone with 52,000-plus Specimens Fully Digitized

The herbarium is the heart of research at the Garden. A major priority of the herbarium is to digitize the collection by photographing the specimens and transcribing the related information recorded by botanists. Staff and volunteers made significant strides in reaching this goal last year. “The herbarium ended 2022 with complete transcriptions of 52,674 specimens,” says Herbarium Collections Manager Ashley Bordelon.

Read More »
Newsletter

FWBG Experts and Volunteers Digitize Records of Renowned Botanist in Cutting-Edge Project

Botanist Sherwin Carlquist (1930-2021) was a legend in his field, a prolific researcher who made major contributions to plant systematics, plant anatomy, island biology and wood anatomy. He traveled the world collecting plant specimens, photographing plants in the field and collecting data about ecosystems. Hard work by our experts and volunteers means scientists interested in studying Carlquist’s work will soon have a new type of digital resource giving them unprecedented context for his findings: an extended specimen network. Assuming, that is, that they can decipher Carlquist’s handwriting. 

Read More »